Skip to the story | Text edition home | Full site | Accessibility

Reported by us | South Coast

Judge sets Lindsay Clancy's second trial for March 29, 2027, after prosecutors say the case needs a jury

Judge William Sullivan picked the date after prosecutors said their first opening was in May and the defense asked for April. A status hearing is set for Dec. 30 and a final pretrial conference for Feb. 18, 2027.

By the SC360 Courts and Crime Desk | Published Nov. 16, 2026 | Last verified Nov. 16, 2026, 1:35 p.m. ET

SOUTH COAST A Plymouth Superior Court judge on Monday set Lindsay Clancy's second murder trial for March 29, 2027, after prosecutors said the charges she faces require a jury and asked for a later start.

Judge William Sullivan picked the date over the prosecution's objection at a hearing of about 15 minutes in Plymouth, with Clancy in the courtroom. Jury selection begins that day, according to the dates read into the record at the end of the hearing, with a status hearing Dec. 30 and a final pretrial conference Feb. 18, 2027, both at 9 a.m.

The order puts the Duxbury mother, charged in the 2023 deaths of her three children, ages 5, 3 and 8 months, before a second jury nearly seven months after her first trial ended Sept. 4 with a deadlocked jury, The Associated Press reported.

What prosecutors told the judge

Sullivan opened by noting that he had ruled on the motions argued two weeks earlier, then asked the prosecution where the case stood. "Given what the charges are, it requires a jury trial, so we'd be ready to pick a jury trial date," a prosecutor answered, adding that prosecutors had not heard from the defense about its direction for the trial.

A Plymouth County grand jury indicted Clancy in September 2023 on three counts each of murder and strangulation, District Attorney Timothy J. Cruz's office announced at the time. A Superior Court defendant may give up a jury and be tried by a judge, except in first-degree murder cases, which must be tried by a jury, the district attorney's office explains on its website.

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington told the judge he took the prosecution's answer as a signal. "The die has been cast," he said. "I think you can read between the lines that when they say that the case is going to require a jury, that it's an indirect comment from the DA that they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments, so we will pick a trial date."

Prosecutors did not name in court the degree of murder they will ask a second jury to weigh. In October, the AP reported that prosecutors could retry her on first-degree murder charges, try her only on lesser charges such as second-degree murder or manslaughter, or drop the case.

How the date was set

Sullivan said he wanted a March date, as he had suggested at the Nov. 2 hearing. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague said her calendar and that of Assistant District Attorney Shanan Buckingham, who is trying the case with her, were "pretty full with other murder trials," many older than this case and some still waiting on a first trial date, and that their first availability was in May.

Reddington proposed April and said the other cases could be moved. "Cases are continued all the time," he said. "I think it's readily apparent that this is a case that needs to be tried." The prosecution pointed to an April trial in a 2014 homicide case and to defendants held in jail who have yet to get a first trial date.

"I don't have all of those cases in front of me. I've got this case in front of me," Sullivan said. "Generally the sooner the case is retried, the better it is for all of the parties, including the attorneys, rather than waiting a year to get something done." A date in March or April, he said, gives everybody about four months to prepare.

April 19 and April 12 were proposed first, the prosecution asked for April 26, and April 5 came up next. Sullivan then suggested March 15, saying the other case could be continued, and when prosecutors said Buckingham starts a murder trial March 8, he offered March 22. When they said that left her no time to prepare, he settled on March 29.

What comes next

Sullivan said the Dec. 30 status hearing would take up any new discovery or motions, though he said he does not expect any, along with the trial's logistics, including security and the media.

A prosecutor also raised a possible appeal of Sullivan's Nov. 9 decision denying the defense motion to dismiss the case on double jeopardy grounds, saying it could affect the trial date. Martin G. Weinberg, a lawyer on Clancy's defense team, wrote to Boston.com after that ruling that he expects an appeal to the Supreme Judicial Court in the "very near future." The defense answered Monday that an appeal "is not going to affect the trial date at all." Sullivan said he would set the dates and see what happens on any other issues.

Our earlier report covers the Nov. 9 rulings and the arguments behind them.

How the case got here

At the first trial, Clancy's lawyers argued she was not criminally responsible because of postpartum psychosis and did not dispute that she carried out the killings, the AP reported; prosecutors argued she was responsible. Duxbury police received the 911 call on the evening of Jan. 24, 2023, according to the district attorney's 2023 release. Clancy is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

The case returns to Plymouth Superior Court for the status hearing at 9 a.m. Wednesday, Dec. 30.

Label: Reported by us, from the town's posted records.

Notes

Everything said in court Monday comes from the courtroom pool camera's live stream of the whole hearing, carried by The Associated Press, which we reviewed and transcribed Nov. 16; the dates are as the court read them into the record. The charges, the children's ages and the date of the 911 call come from the Plymouth County district attorney's Sept. 15, 2023, release, and the jury rule from its Plymouth County Courts page. The Nov. 9 ruling and Martin Weinberg's statement are as Boston.com reported them, and the first trial's end and the defense at that trial as The Associated Press reported them; we read each in full Nov. 16. We checked each date and weekday against a calendar. The children, the holdout juror and other defendants are not named. Any comment from the district attorney's office or Clancy's lawyers will be added.

Corrections

No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.

Sources (5)

  1. The Associated Press: live stream of the courtroom pool camera, "LIVE: Judge schedules Lindsay Clancy's retrial for March," Plymouth Superior Court, Nov. 16, 2026Everything said in court Monday: the prosecution's jury trial answer, Reddington's remarks, Sprague's calendar, the dates floated, Sullivan's remarks, the March 29 setting over the Commonwealth's objection, the Dec. 30 status and Feb. 18 final pretrial conference read into the record at about 15:26 into the video, and the appeal exchange. Stream began 9 a.m. EST; the whole hearing, about 15 minutes, was reviewed and transcribed as text notes Nov. 16, 2026, 11:10 a.m. to noon EST.
  2. Plymouth County District Attorney: Duxbury woman indicted on charges that she murdered her three children, Sept. 15, 2023The indictments on three counts each of murder and strangulation, the children's ages, the Jan. 24, 2023, call and District Attorney Timothy J. Cruz. Read in full Nov. 16, 2026, 11:22 a.m. EST.
  3. Plymouth County District Attorney: Plymouth County CourtsThat a Superior Court defendant may waive a jury except in first-degree murder cases, and that Plymouth Superior Court sits inside the Plymouth Trial Court on Obery Street. Read in full Nov. 16, 2026, 11:35 a.m. EST.
  4. Boston.com: Judge denies Lindsay Clancy's motion to dismiss murder charges, by Brendan Nordstrom, Nov. 9, 2026The Nov. 9 denial of the double jeopardy motion, citing court records, and Weinberg's written statement on an appeal. Read in full Nov. 16, 2026, noon EST.
  5. PBS NewsHour (The Associated Press): Judge denies motion asking for Lindsay Clancy to be found not guilty due to lack of evidence, by Michael Casey, Oct. 1, 2026The Sept. 4 end of the first trial with a deadlocked jury, the postpartum psychosis defense and the prosecution's options for a second trial. Read in full Nov. 16, 2026, noon EST.

This story on the full site