Skip to the story | Text edition home | Full site | Accessibility

Reported by us | Plymouth

Plymouth zoning board continues 186-unit Court Street senior living plan to Dec. 21 amid height concerns

Neighbors and the owner of the liquor store that would stay on the site raised building height and parking, and board members asked the developers to rethink where pickleball courts sit.

By the SC360 Breaking and Public Safety Desk | Published Nov. 17, 2026 | Last verified Nov. 17, 2026, 12:58 a.m. ET

PLYMOUTH A plan to turn Plymouth's vacant Benny's Plaza into a 186-unit senior living community returns to the Zoning Board of Appeals on Dec. 21, after the board's first look Monday, Nov. 16.

The board continued the hearing so a town peer review and a meeting with public works engineers can be finished, and the chairman said public comment will reopen then. Neighbors spent much of Monday's hearing on how tall the buildings would be and where people would park.

What is proposed

CGMA Plymouth LLC is seeking special permits to demolish two existing buildings and a kiosk at 179 and 181-183 Court St. and to build an assisted living facility and two mixed-use buildings, all above the town's 35-foot height limit, the agenda shows. The two buildings coming down are the empty plaza and a vacant former bank, the developers said.

Seamus Joyce of HYM Investment Group, the Boston developer, told the board the senior building would have 186 units of independent living, assisted living and memory care, run by Experience Senior Living under the name the Gallery at Plymouth. NexCore Group, the Colorado company that owns Experience Senior Living, would own the site, and Pioppi's liquor store would stay. The building would be four stories on the side deeper in the lot and step down to three toward Nelson Street, Joyce said, and the extra height reflects uses the Select Board asked the team to add.

At the front, Matt Sheridan of Sheridan Home Builders plans about 8,000 square feet of shops with 21 rental apartments above, 11 studios, six one-bedroom and four two-bedroom units. A quarter would be set aside as affordable, which lets all 21 count toward the town's affordable housing inventory, and he said even the market-rate units would be priced near the 80% area median income level, with the affordable units closer to 60%. The middle of the site would hold a lawn, two pickleball courts, a dog run and bocce courts, which Joyce said the team would like to keep open to the public.

The plan provides 220 parking spaces, one more than zoning requires for the mix of uses, Joyce said, and the team would replace a town storm drain, which Joyce put at about 32 inches, with a 42-inch pipe. The developers hope to seek a building permit in the spring and break ground in June or July 2027, with about 24 months to build the senior building.

Height and parking

Board members asked the team to consider moving the pickleball courts so more parking sits near the shops, and one asked that traffic counts include the intersection of Route 3A and Samoset Street. A member who is not sitting on the case said the team would have to prove to him that a height of 62 feet fits with the rest of the neighborhood. "Because to me, I don't think it does," he said. The chairman noted that the two front buildings are 38 feet tall, not 35, because zoning on Route 3A does not allow homes on the first floor, so they need shops below the apartments.

A Nelson Street resident said people who visit Nelson Park, the beach and the bike path park on the lot now and asked whether the project needs so many units. The owner of an abutting business, who said he does not object to the senior building at the back, asked the board to deny the permits as proposed or at least hold the two buildings along Court Street to the 35-foot limit. Through his attorney, the owner of Pioppi's asked for 32 designated spaces for the store, saying his lease covers the common parking as well as the spaces in front, and he noted that his grandparents built the plaza.

Joyce said the team wants to work out the height limits in the Pioppi's lease and hopes to reach an agreement on a height that works. The attorney for CGMA Plymouth said much of what neighbors raised, including the pickleball courts, open space and shops, came from multiple meetings with the Select Board and town officials. The Select Board voted 5-0 on July 7 to approve a development agreement for the site, and its minutes say Assistant Town Manager Lauren Lind told the board that signing would not limit the Zoning Board of Appeals or the Planning Board, which the developer also goes before, South Coast 360 reported Nov. 11.

South Coast 360 previewed the case Nov. 11, and the July agreement allows up to 195 senior units.

Other business

The board granted a special permit letting Kreg and Lisa DeMole keep an attached garage at 31 Farnham Drive that sits 14.7 feet from the side line, about 3 inches inside the 15-foot setback, and approved its Aug. 17 minutes.

What comes next

The hearing resumes Monday, Dec. 21. The board meets in the Great Hall at Town Hall, 26 Court St., and its meetings air on The Local Seen.

Label: Reported by us, from the town's posted records.

Notes

Every vote, figure and quote comes from our own coverage of the Nov. 16 hearing on The Local Seen, checked against the time stamps in our transcript of the posted recording and, where it covers the same stretch, our live transcript. Case details come from the Nov. 16 agenda, and the July development agreement vote from the Select Board minutes as reported in our Nov. 11 preview. The quote from the board member matches word for word in both transcripts. We read them on Nov. 16 and checked each date and weekday against a calendar. Not heard: the town's peer review and the public works comments on the drainage plan are not yet posted.

Corrections

No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.

Sources (3)

  1. Plymouth Zoning Board of Appeals: 11/16/26The Local Seen, meeting recording, 110 minutes, called to order about 6:01 p.m., adjourned about 7:45 p.m. Every vote, figure and quote, from our own live transcript and a full transcript of the recording; time stamps in the evidence file. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
  2. Agenda, Zoning Board of Appeals, November 16, 2026Town of Plymouth, 1 page, posted Nov. 10, 2026. Cases 4239 (31 Farnham Drive) and 4237 (179 and 181-183 Court St.), special permits listed, Aug. 17 minutes. Read Nov. 11 and Nov. 16, 2026.
  3. Plymouth zoning board takes up Court Street plan for up to 195 senior living units on Nov. 16South Coast 360, Nov. 11, 2026, from the agenda and the Select Board's July 7 development agreement. Read Nov. 16, 2026.

This story on the full site