A typed table headed "WAREHAM Precinct 1" from the town's recount certification, listing John Robert Gaskey, Sarah G. Hewins, all others, blanks and total votes cast, with the original tallies typed and the new tallies handwritten in red: Gaskey 709 to 704, Hewins 840 to 805, total votes cast 1,642 to 1,595.
Wareham's Precinct 1 tally, one of six precinct pages in the certification of recount results the town posted Nov. 20, with the original count typed and the recount's count handwritten. Image: Town of Wareham

Updated 3:35 p.m. Nov. 21, 2026.

Democrat Sarah Hewins still leads Republican state Rep. John Gaskey in the 2nd Plymouth District race after Wareham's recount, but her margin shrank to 58 votes, with Carver's recount still to come Monday.

Wareham's recount on Friday, Nov. 20, gave Hewins 5,266 votes and Gaskey 4,580 in town, according to the certification of recount results Town Clerk Lisa Johnson signed that day and the town posted at 6:48 p.m. Hewins lost 66 votes from Wareham's certified count of 5,332, and Gaskey lost 17 from his 4,597.

The race decides who represents Wareham, Carver and part of Middleborough in the next Legislature. Hewins led 9,421 to 9,314 across the three towns in the certified count, and the towns' results go to the Secretary of the Commonwealth to be certified, The Wareham Week reported Nov. 18. With Wareham's recounted figures in place, Hewins has 9,355 votes to Gaskey's 9,297, by our math, a margin the Week also put at 58.

What the recount changed

The biggest swings in the candidates' counts came in Precinct 1, where Hewins went from 840 votes to 805 and Gaskey from 709 to 704, and in Precinct 3, where Hewins went from 989 to 951 and Gaskey from 754 to 743, the certification shows. In the other four precincts, neither candidate's count moved by more than five votes.

Gaskey carried Precinct 5, 870 to 866, the only one of Wareham's six precincts he won in either count. Hewins carried Precinct 2, where the most votes in the race were cast, 1,050 to 811.

Blank ballots in the race dropped from 541 to 452 in the recount, and votes for all others went from four to three. The form lists 10,301 total votes cast in the race after the recount, 173 fewer than the 10,474 in the original tally. Most of that drop came in Precincts 1, 2 and 3, and the form does not say what accounts for it.

Johnson told The Wareham Week that a hand recount was needed to read voters' intent on some ballots, and that a voting machine counts a ballot with an anomaly, such as a pen mark in more than one oval, as a blank vote. "The results are the final results," Johnson told the paper. Volunteers checked ballots in Town Hall most of the day, and the results were announced after 5 p.m., the Week reported. Both candidates asked for the Wareham recount, Johnson said.

Both candidates spoke with the Week at Town Hall during the count. Hewins said she was reluctant to say much until the results were certified. "We just want to see it done right and fairly, and let the chips fall where they may," she said. Gaskey called the past few weeks "very stressful" but said he appreciated the transparency of a public recount. "I think there's been a few hiccups, but all in all I think it's going really well," he said.

Asked about the Wareham result, Gaskey wrote in an email statement to South Coast 360 on Saturday that "Friday and Monday are what the election process is all about." In "this new era of multi week voting and mail-in voting," he wrote, it is "imperative that we have the ability to confirm our elections," and the process "gives insight to the rarely seen processes in the handling of ballots." On the recount, which by our math took 49 votes off Hewins' districtwide lead, he wrote, "It was good to see the results work in my favor," and added that "there are still questions to be answered," though he did not say which, and that, "like the voters, I want to be confident in the results…win or lose."

Hewins answered South Coast 360's request for comment by email Saturday afternoon, writing that the votes in the race, "including those in all three towns, Carver, Wareham, and South Middleborough," have "not been certified by the Secretary of State's office." "We will reserve comments for when those results are certified," she wrote.

What happens next

Carver's Board of Registrars will recount ballots in the race Monday, Nov. 23, from 9:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. or until the count is done, in Select Board Meeting Room 1 at Carver Town Hall, 108 Main St., according to the board's posted notice. Gaskey carried Carver 2,820 to 2,613 in the town's official results, a 207-vote edge there. Monday is the last day towns have to recount their votes in the race, the Week reported.

A recount was also requested in Middleborough, but the Secretary of the Commonwealth did not direct the Middleborough Town Clerk's Office to recount its votes, the Week reported. Gaskey carried the district's part of Middleborough, 1,897 to 1,476, in the certified count, according to the Week.

Under state law, General Laws chapter 54, section 135, the registrars at a town recount open the sealed ballot envelopes, count the ballots again, blanks included, and rule on any protested vote, and a candidate may examine the precinct clerks' records and ask for a count of the voters checked off on the voting lists.

How we got here

Hewins held an 89-vote lead in the unofficial count the morning after the Nov. 3 election, The Wareham Week reported. Gaskey later asked the Secretary of the Commonwealth to look into what he called errors in how Wareham's clerk's office reported its unofficial count, after a spreadsheet from the office showed him gaining 171 votes on Nov. 6 and an updated one showed 41 on Nov. 9, the Week reported. A spokesperson for the secretary, Debra O'Malley, told the Week the difference was likely caused by data entry errors and that any results before state certification are unofficial. South Coast 360 reported on the unsettled race Nov. 11.

Gaskey was elected to the seat in 2024 after beating longtime Rep. Susan Gifford in that year's Republican primary. Hewins, a Carver Select Board member, ran against Gifford in 2016 and 2018 and mounted a late write-in campaign against Gaskey in 2024, the Week reported.

Label: Reported by us, from the town's posted records.

Notes

Every Wareham figure comes from the Certification of Recount Results the town clerk signed Nov. 20 and the town posted that evening, read Nov. 21, and every precinct row adds up to its total. Carver's figures and recount time come from Carver's official results and the Carver registrars' notice. The certified district totals, the Middleborough figures and recount status, the clerk's comments, both candidates' remarks at the recount and the secretary's spokesperson's explanation come from The Wareham Week, credited in the story; Wareham's 5,332 and Carver's 2,613 and 2,820 from the town records leave exactly the Week's Middleborough figures inside its district totals. The 9,355 to 9,297 district count and the 173-vote change in total votes are our own math. We checked each date and weekday against a calendar. This story was updated Nov. 21, 2026, with Rep. Gaskey's email statement to South Coast 360, sent from his House email at 12:46 p.m. in answer to our questions; his words are quoted as he wrote them, and the ellipsis in his last sentence is his own. The 49-vote change in Hewins' lead is our math (66 minus 17). Sarah Hewins answered our Nov. 21 request by email at 2:50 p.m. that day; her words are quoted as she wrote them.

Corrections

No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.

Sources (10)

  1. Town of Wareham: Certification of Recount Results, November 3, 2026 State Election (Representative in General Court, seven-page scanned PDF, created Nov. 20, 2026, 6:11 p.m.)Signed by the clerk Nov. 20, 2026; original and new tallies for Gaskey, Hewins, all others, blanks and total votes cast in Precincts 1 to 6. Read Nov. 21, 2026.
  2. Town of Wareham Alert Center: November 3, 2026 State Election Recount ResultsPosted Nov. 20, 2026, 6:48 p.m., linking the certification. Read Nov. 21, 2026.
  3. The Wareham Week: Recount results narrow gap, Hewins still in leadTown Clerk Lisa Johnson's explanation and quote; results announced after 5 p.m.; both candidates asked for the Wareham recount; Carver recount Nov. 23 is the last day; Middleborough not directed to recount; margin of 58. Read Nov. 21, 2026.
  4. The Wareham Week: Hewins wins 2nd Plymouth state rep race, results will be recounted (Christian Uva, Nov. 18, 2026)Certified district totals 9,421 to 9,314; Wareham 5,332 to 4,597; Middleborough 1,897 to 1,476; Hewins a Carver Select Board member; her runs in 2016, 2018 and 2024; recounts requested in all three towns, ordered in Wareham and Carver; results go to the Secretary of the Commonwealth to be certified; Hewins' and Gaskey's remarks at the Wareham recount Nov. 20 (story updated after the recount). Read Nov. 20 and 21, 2026.
  5. Town of Carver: Meeting of the Board of Registrars, Monday, Nov. 23, 2026 (posted Nov. 19)9:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. or conclusion, Select Board Meeting Room 1, Carver Town Hall, 108 Main St.: "To re-count ballots for the State Representative in General Court race." Read Nov. 20, 2026.
  6. Town of Carver: November 3, 2026 Official State Election Results (scanned PDF, created Nov. 19, 2026)Representative in General Court, Carver: Gaskey 2,820, Hewins 2,613 (page 3). Read Nov. 20, 2026.
  7. Town of Wareham: Election Results pageLists the Certification of Recount Results for the Nov. 3, 2026 election. Read Nov. 21, 2026.
  8. The Wareham Week: Hewins appears victorious with 89-vote margin in state rep race (Christian Uva and Nick Mossman, Nov. 4, 2026)The 89-vote unofficial margin; Gaskey's 2024 primary win over Gifford. Read Nov. 11, 2026.
  9. The Wareham Week: State rep race results still unclear one week out (Christian Uva, Nov. 10, 2026)Gaskey's request to the Secretary of the Commonwealth about Wareham's reporting; the Nov. 6 and Nov. 9 spreadsheets (171 and 41 votes gained); spokesperson Debra O'Malley on data entry errors and unofficial results. Read Nov. 11 and 21, 2026.
  10. Massachusetts General Laws, chapter 54, section 135What the registrars do at a town recount; candidates' right to examine the voting lists and records. Read Nov. 20, 2026.