
WAREHAM Updated 4:35 p.m. Nov. 17, 2026.
Residents of Wareham and four nearby towns gave A.D. Makepeace notice Monday that they plan to sue over earth removal on Tihonet Road unless the company stops the work within 21 days.
The 11-page letter, dated Nov. 16 and sent by certified mail, is not a lawsuit. A state law, Chapter 214, Section 7A, lets 10 or more Massachusetts residents ask a Superior Court judge to stop damage to the environment that breaks an environmental law, but only after giving written notice at least 21 days ahead to the party accused, the agency that enforces the law and the attorney general. If Makepeace does not stop the work at 140 Tihonet Road and fix what the letter calls violations within that time, the group "will file a Verified Complaint" in Plymouth County Superior Court, the letter says.
A.D. Makepeace has called the work site preparation for an approved solar project. "This is nothing more than site preparation for an approved project as occurs across America daily," Linda Burke, the company's vice president of marketing and communication, wrote to South Coast 360 on Nov. 12. "Again, this has no impact on Tihonet Pond." She wrote that the town approved the project in 2020 and 2021 and that it was also approved at the state level. South Coast 360 asked the company about the notice Monday night and had not heard back by late Tuesday morning.
The notice itself quotes a March 18, 2021, letter in which company President and CEO James F. Kane told the Conservation Commission that "any material removed from the site, will be used for our on-going agricultural activities, and is therefore not subject to earth removal permitting." Kane also wrote that the company "will communicate and coordinate with the Board of Selectmen as the earth removal permit issuing authority," according to the notice.
Who sent it
Daniel J. Goodrich, a lawyer with the Boston firm Murphy & King, signed the letter for what it calls the "Ten Residents Group." A footnote lists 14 people from Wareham, Carver, Plymouth, Halifax and Plympton, along with the Community Land and Water Coalition, a Plymouth nonprofit that has opposed the company's projects before.
The letter is addressed to Kane at 158 Tihonet Road, to Select Board Chair Sarah Corbitt and Conservation Commission Chair Sandra Slavin, and to MassDEP Commissioner Bonnie Heiple, Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell, Energy and Environmental Affairs Secretary Rebecca Tepper and the Massachusetts Historical Commission. Meg Sheehan, a lawyer who works without pay for the coalition, emailed a copy Monday afternoon to the attorney general's office, state energy and environmental review staff, a state senator, a state representative, South Coast 360 and others.
What the letter says
The letter says Makepeace has clear-cut about 83 acres of forest on the east shore of Tihonet Pond and is removing, or is about to remove, up to 2 million cubic yards of sand and earth, a job it says takes tens of thousands of truck trips over several years. The state maps the land as BioMap core habitat for rare species, the letter says, and it says the land lies over the Plymouth-Carver Sole Source Aquifer, the region's drinking water supply.
The 2 million figure comes from the town's engineer, the letter says, and a March 2021 letter to the Planning Board from Charles L. Rowley, the engineer who reviewed the plans for the board, used it and recommended that the board's special permit be "subject to the receipt of approval" for that removal under the town's earth removal bylaw. The project's 2022 state environmental filing put the amount lower, saying "up to 1.2 million cubic yards of material may be removed from this site," as South Coast 360 reported Nov. 14. The same filing says "applicable state and local regulatory authorities have approved the project."
The work is going ahead, the letter says, without an earth removal permit from the Select Board, without a Conservation Commission wetlands permit for the earth removal under the town bylaw and the state Wetlands Protection Act, without the town stormwater permit required for disturbing 20,000 square feet or more, and in violation of state air rules on dust.
Wareham's earth removal bylaw requires a Select Board permit but does not apply to "normal construction, maintenance or improvement of land in cranberry related activities or other agricultural use." It also does not apply to earth moved under an approved subdivision plan, to street and utility work, or to "excavation and grading of land incidental to construction of a duly permitted structure." The town's stormwater bylaw likewise exempts normal maintenance and improvement of land in agricultural use, and construction that needed site plan review or a special permit, when the plans include stormwater provisions and notice is filed with the town's stormwater authority. It also exempts work entirely within the Conservation Commission's jurisdiction when the plans include stormwater provisions and the commission has issued an order of conditions for the site.
Under the earth removal bylaw, removing earth without a required permit carries fines of $50 for a first offense, $100 for a second and $200 for each one after that, with each truckload counted as a separate offense, and when work starts without a permit the town's engineer measures what was taken at the property owner's expense.
The letter says the sand is being removed for commercial sale and that such work is not exempt. The letter adds that Makepeace has offered no documents showing the sand will go to its roughly 1,625 acres of cranberry bogs, and that this much sand would cover those bogs about 9 inches deep, when UMass Extension practice calls for one-half inch to 2 inches every two to five years.
The Conservation Commission did issue an order of conditions for the solar project on April 28, 2021, under MassDEP file SE76-2611, the letter says, but the letter says that order allowed only solar work in buffer zones near wetlands and did not cover the earth removal, which it says the Planning Board and Makepeace treated as separate from the solar project. The letter also says dust from digging and hauling, including respirable crystalline silica, which the letter calls a human carcinogen, reaches nearby homes, and that a 2020 archaeological survey found signs of Native American occupation on the site, including an Early Woodland projectile point, but did not evaluate the earth removal.
The residents asked the town Nov. 10, through a public records request, phone calls and email, for any earth removal permit or exemption decision for the site, and the town had not answered by the letter's date, the letter says. Wareham Town Administrator Derek Sullivan has not answered questions South Coast 360 sent Nov. 10 on whether the town issued such a permit or granted an exemption.
The letter cites a 2025 Appeals Court decision in Currence v. A.D. Makepeace, a case over earth removal in Carver. A Superior Court judge had dismissed that suit, brought by 10 residents and a nonprofit. The Appeals Court revived their Section 7A claim against A.D. Makepeace and its subsidiary, Read Custom Soils, at three of the six Carver sites named in the suit, and upheld the dismissal of the rest of the case, including the claim over three solar sites where the work was finished and the claims against Carver's earth removal committee. The court ruled on the residents' allegations, which it had to accept as true at that early stage, and did not decide whether the company harmed the environment; it noted that the facts on the ground may now be different. It also left open whether the company can be held liable under Section 7A for work a permit allows. In January, the Supreme Judicial Court denied the companies' request to review the decision, and the case went back to Plymouth Superior Court, the Appeals Court docket shows.
The letter quotes the court as saying that "the systematic stripping of earth and topsoil" counts as damage to "soil resources" under the law. It also says the court held that an earth removal bylaw falls within Section 7A, which covers only laws whose major purpose is to prevent or minimize damage to the environment. The court reached that conclusion about Carver's earth removal bylaw, after reviewing that bylaw's own provisions.
What the group asks for
The letter demands that Makepeace stop all earth removal at the site at once and take no further action until it has a Select Board earth removal permit and a Conservation Commission permit for the removal. It also asks the company to account for all the earth taken from the site, pay the town the 25 cents a cubic yard the letter says is required, control dust and diesel exhaust, restore the land and confirm in writing within 21 days that it will comply.
If the company does not, the group says it will ask the court to halt the work until the permits are issued, to declare that the work breaks the laws the letter cites, to order dust controls and restoration, and to award costs, including expert witness fees. It says it may ask a judge sooner for a temporary restraining order and to waive the 21-day wait, which the law allows when irreparable damage would otherwise result.
What happens next
The letter's 21 days run to Dec. 7, by South Coast 360's count. Under the same law, a company sued this way has a defense if it is under, and complying in good faith with, a court-enforceable administrative plan to abate the damage complained of, unless a danger to public health and safety leads the court to keep the case. Any such case is to be advanced for a speedy trial and cannot be settled without the court's approval. A judge who rules for the residents may award their costs, including expert witness fees, but not lawyers' fees or damages. The court may also require the residents to post a bond of $500 to $5,000 to cover any costs assessed against them if they lose.
The Select Board, which issues earth removal permits under the town bylaw, next meets Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 7 p.m. in Room 520 of the Multi-Service Center, 48 Marion Road, with resident comments on the agenda and a Zoom option. The board's office can be reached at 508-291-3100, ext. 3101, or selectboard@wareham.gov.
Clarification, Nov. 17, 2026: An earlier version of this story said the letter quotes the Appeals Court as "finding" that stripping earth and topsoil is damage to soil resources. The 2025 decision in Currence v. A.D. Makepeace revived a dismissed claim over earth removal in Carver and did not rule on whether the company harmed the environment; the story now says so. The story also now says that the Conservation Commission issued an order of conditions for the solar project in 2021, which the letter says did not cover the earth removal. An earlier version said South Coast 360 had not asked the company about the notice; South Coast 360 asked Monday night.
Correction, Nov. 17, 2026: An earlier version of this story overstated the 2025 Currence decision. It said the Appeals Court revived the residents' claim against the company without saying the claim was revived at only three of six Carver sites and the rest of the case stayed dismissed, and it repeated the letter's description of the court's holding on earth removal bylaws without saying the court ruled on Carver's bylaw. The story now says both, and adds that the court left open whether work a permit allows can violate Section 7A and that the Supreme Judicial Court declined to review the decision.
Label: Reported by us, from the town's posted records.
Notes
Every fact comes from the Nov. 16 notice of intent to sue and the coalition email that carried it, Chapter 214, Section 7A of the General Laws, the project's 2022 state environmental filing, a 2021 letter from the engineer who reviewed the plans for the Planning Board, Wareham's general bylaws, the Select Board's Nov. 17 agenda and web page, A.D. Makepeace's Nov. 12 email to South Coast 360, and the law firm's page for Goodrich. The 2021 Kane letter and the 2025 Appeals Court decision are quoted as the notice quotes them. The Dec. 7 date is our own count of 21 days from the letter's date. We read the records on Nov. 14, 16 and 17, 2026, and checked each date and weekday against a calendar. Not heard: A.D. Makepeace was asked about the notice Monday at 10:19 p.m. and had not answered by Tuesday at 11:22 a.m.; its earlier statements are quoted. The account of the Currence decision comes from the court's opinion, No. 24-P-666, and the Appeals Court's docket for the case, both read Nov. 17, 2026. Wareham Town Administrator Derek Sullivan, asked Nov. 10, has not answered.
Corrections
- Correction, Nov. 17, 2026: An earlier version of this story overstated the 2025 Currence decision. It said the Appeals Court revived the residents' claim against the company without saying the claim was revived at only three of six Carver sites and the rest of the case stayed dismissed, and it repeated the letter's description of the court's holding on earth removal bylaws without saying the court ruled on Carver's bylaw. The story now says both, and adds that the court left open whether work a permit allows can violate Section 7A and that the Supreme Judicial Court declined to review the decision.
If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.
Sources (19)
- Currence v. A.D. Makepeace Co., Massachusetts Appeals Court, No. 24-P-666 (Sept. 19, 2025), slip opinionCarver earth removal; the court vacated the dismissal of the residents' Section 7A count. Cited at 106 Mass. App. Ct. 71 in the notice.
- Currence v. A.D. Makepeace Co., 106 Mass. App. Ct. 71 (2025), opinion text on CourtListenerSept. 19, 2025, opinion by Justice Englander: Section 7A dismissal vacated as to sites 1, 2 and 3 against Makepeace and Read Custom Soils, judgment otherwise affirmed; decided on the complaint's allegations (footnote 3); permit question left open (footnote 16). Read Nov. 17, 2026.
- Massachusetts Appeals Court docket 2024-P-0666, Currence v. A.D. Makepeace Co.Decision Sept. 19, 2025; FAR-30606 filed by A.D. Makepeace and Read Custom Soils Oct. 10, 2025, denied Jan. 15, 2026; rescript to Plymouth Superior Court (2283CV00585). Read Nov. 17, 2026.
- Rich May, P.C.: Currence v. Makepeace and What It Means (Oct. 3, 2025)Summary of the Sept. 19, 2025, decision: Carver's earth removal bylaw; the trial judge's dismissal of the Section 7A count vacated. Read Nov. 17, 2026.
- Email from South Coast 360 to Linda Burke, A.D. Makepeace (Nov. 16, 2026, 10:19 p.m.)Questions on the notice; no answer as of Nov. 17, 2026, 11:22 a.m. Read Nov. 17, 2026.
- Notice of Intent to Sue Pursuant to M.G.L. c. 214, s. 7A, 140 Tihonet Road, Wareham, signed by Daniel J. Goodrich for the Ten Residents Group (Nov. 16, 2026, 11 pages)Courtesy copy emailed to South Coast 360 and state officials by the Community Land and Water Coalition, Mon. Nov. 16, 2026, 4:43 p.m. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 214, Section 7ATen or more residents, 21-day certified mail notice, waiver for irreparable damage, good-faith compliance defense, speedy trial, no compromise without court approval, costs but not attorney fees or damages, $500 to $5,000 bond. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- ADM Tihonet Mixed Use Development Final Environmental Impact Report, EEA No. 13940 (2022)Up to 1.2 million cubic yards at 140 Tihonet Road; applicable state and local authorities have approved the project. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- Letter from Charles L. Rowley, PE, PLS, to the Wareham Planning Board, Re: 140 Tihonet Road Solar (March 5, 2021)Approximately 2,000,000 yards of sand; shared with South Coast 360 by the coalition, Nov. 12, 2026. Read Nov. 14, 2026.
- Town of Wareham General By-Laws, revised August 2025, Division IV, Article III, Earth Removal Regulations, and Division V, Article XI, Stormwater ManagementSelect Board permit; exemptions, including cranberry and agricultural work and grading incidental to a permitted structure; $0.25 per cubic yard fee; fines per truckload; stormwater permit at 20,000 square feet and its agricultural, site plan review and special permit exemptions. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- Email from Linda Burke, A.D. Makepeace (Nov. 12, 2026, 10:17 a.m.)Answer to South Coast 360 questions on the Tihonet Road work. Read Nov. 14, 2026.
- Emails from Meg Sheehan, Community Land and Water Coalition (Nov. 12 and Nov. 16, 2026)Pro bono attorney for the coalition; courtesy copy of the notice and its recipients. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- Wareham Select Board agenda, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 20267 p.m., Room 520, 48 Marion Road, Zoom, resident comments. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- Town of Wareham: Select BoardOffice phone 508-291-3100, ext. 3101; selectboard@wareham.gov; Chair Sarah Corbitt. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 66, Section 1010 business days to furnish records or respond in writing. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- A.D. Makepeace Company: ContactLinda Burke, Vice President, Marketing and Communication. Read Nov. 10, 2026.
- The Wareham Week: Activists call for full review of Makepeace's work (June 6, 2022)Coalition objection to closing the state review of the company's Tihonet development. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- Murphy & King: Daniel J. GoodrichShareholder, Boston office. Read Nov. 16, 2026.
- South Coast 360: Makepeace says Wareham solar work has begun where a filing says up to 1.2 million cubic yards may be removed (Nov. 14, 2026)Earlier reporting on the site, the 2021 town votes and the Nov. 10 questions to the town. Read Nov. 16, 2026.







